← All samples
Sample report

Novelty Report

Generated August 25, 2026 · mimiic.app

Written by hand from the same USPTO documents the pipeline searches, in the exact format a generated report uses. Live reports are produced by the model, not by hand.

The idea

A coffee maker that brews one cup at a time from a sealed single-serve pod that has the paper filter built into the pod

Assessment

This is one of the most thoroughly claimed spaces in consumer products. Patents 5840189 (the cartridge) and 5325765 (the brewer) together cover the idea as described element for element; they are the references that matter, and their expiry in 2012 is the only reason generic pods are on the shelf today. The live activity is in construction details — paper-only pods (20140342058) and how the filter is joined and released (12428218, granted 2025) — and that is where any new claim would have to sit. Before going further, read 12428218's claims closely, since it is in force, and decide whether a paper-only, adhesive-free construction or a machine-readable pod is the direction worth the filing cost.

Closest prior art

584018990% overlap

Covers: Claim 1 covers the cartridge itself: an impermeable hollow base with a flat bottom, a truncated-conical side wall and a lip; a self-supporting filter permanently joined to the interior wall so it divides the base into two chambers; and a pierceable cover sealed to the lip, with the base bottom pierceable for outflow.

Overlap with the idea: This is the K-Cup. A sealed pod with the filter built in and a pierceable top and bottom is exactly what the claim recites; the idea as described falls inside it in every element. The patent expired in 2012, which is why generic pods exist.

Claim elements vs. the idea
Claim elementThe idea
Impermeable hollow base with flat bottom and conical side wallIn your idea
Self-supporting filter permanently joined to the interior wallIn your idea
Filter divides the base into two chambersArguably
Pierceable cover sealed to the lipIn your idea
Base bottom pierceable for outflowIn your idea
532576584% overlap

Covers: Claims the brewing apparatus: a housing with a brewing chamber, an impermeable pierceable cartridge subdivided by a filter element into two chambers with the extract in the first, inlet and outlet piercing means, and liquid injection through the inlet.

Overlap with the idea: Where 5840189 claims the pod, this one claims the machine that uses it. A one-cup brewer that pierces a filter-in-pod cartridge and injects water is the whole of this claim.

Claim elements vs. the idea
Claim elementThe idea
Housing with a brewing chamber receiving the cartridgeIn your idea
Impermeable, pierceable cartridge divided by a filter into two chambersIn your idea
Beverage extract held in the first chamberIn your idea
Inlet piercing means and outlet piercing meansArguably
Liquid injected under pressure through the inletArguably
2014034205862% overlap

Covers: A published application for a single-cup brewing pod made of paper: a paper cup, a paper filter and a paper lid sealed together, aimed at compostability.

Overlap with the idea: Overlaps on the sealed pod with an integrated paper filter. It goes further than the idea by requiring every component to be paper; the idea does not say what the pod body is made of.

Claim elements vs. the idea
Claim elementThe idea
Cup-shaped pod body formed of paperArguably
Paper filter inside the pod bodyIn your idea
Paper lid sealed to the bodyArguably
Pod sealed for single-cup brewingIn your idea
1242821845% overlap

Covers: Granted in 2025: a pod in which an ultrasonic energy director joins the filter's extension to the pod rim and releasably seals it, so the filter can be separated for recycling.

Overlap with the idea: Shares the filter-in-pod construction but claims a specific joining method and a releasable seal. The idea says nothing about how the filter is attached, so the distinguishing elements are absent — and this is a live patent, unlike the Keurig ones.

560571030% overlap

Covers: A 1997 disposable single-cup brewing device: a foldable conical holder with a filter and a dissolvable gelatin valve, used over a cup rather than in a machine.

Overlap with the idea: Same 'one cup, disposable, filter included' aim without the sealed pod or the brewing machine. Relevant mainly as early evidence that the single-serve filter concept predates the cartridge patents.

Apparent white space

The pod and the machine as described are both fully claimed by the two Keurig patents, and both have expired — so the generic idea is free to use but not patentable. The application 20140342058 shows that the all-paper construction was pursued but there is no granted claim in this pool on it, and 12428218 shows the current frontier is how the filter is joined and separated. What none of these claims appear to reach is the pod's interaction with the brewer beyond piercing: pods that identify themselves to the machine, pods whose filter geometry changes extraction, or a paper pod whose seal is formed without adhesive or plastic.

Possible differentiators

This report is automated research assistance for exploring prior art. It is not a legal opinion, not a freedom-to-operate or patentability analysis, and no confidence figure in it is a legal judgment. Coverage: United States patents and published applications only (USPTO full text) — foreign patents and non-patent literature were not searched. Before acting on these findings, consult a registered patent attorney or agent.

Your first Novelty Report is free. No email, no password.

Check your own idea →